The Untold Story of Ron Saunders' Departure from Aston Villa and Peter Withe's Rise
Aston Villa's history is rich with memorable moments and legendary figures. Among these, Ron Saunders and Peter Withe hold special places. Their stories are intertwined with triumphs, challenges, and unexpected turns that have shaped the club’s legacy. This is the inside story of how Ron Saunders, a beloved manager, left Aston Villa, and how Peter Withe became a pivotal player nearly by chance.
Contents
The Signing of Peter Withe: A Masterstroke
Ron Saunders had a clear vision for Aston Villa when he described the signing of Peter Withe as the final piece of his team's puzzle. Withe, a robust striker from Newcastle United, joined Villa in July 1980 for a substantial fee of £555,550. This move would prove to be a game-changer for the club.
Within two years, Withe's contributions were invaluable. He scored 20 goals, significantly aiding Aston Villa in winning the League Championship. More importantly, Withe scored the decisive goal in the European Cup final, securing Villa's place among Europe's elite. His performance far exceeded the expectations set by his transfer fee, making him a fan favorite and a true legend at Villa Park.
A Different Path: The Blocked Signing of Mick Ferguson
The success of Peter Withe was not assured from the beginning. Four months before Withe's arrival, in March 1980, Ron Saunders had his sights set on another striker: Mick Ferguson from Coventry City. Saunders was willing to pay £750,000 for Ferguson, believing he would be a perfect fit for the team.
However, the board was not convinced. Despite Ferguson's impressive goal-scoring record for Coventry, the directors were hesitant to commit such a large sum, especially with the club's finances already stretched. Aston Villa's bank overdraft stood at over £830,000, and the proposed transfer would have nearly doubled this debt. Additionally, match attendances were modest at the time, making the financial risk even greater.
The board's refusal to approve the Ferguson deal was a turning point. Instead of securing Ferguson, Saunders was given the green light to negotiate with Newcastle United for Withe. This decision turned out to be fortuitous, as Withe's impact on the team was profound, while Ferguson's stint at Villa was short-lived. Coventry later sold Ferguson to Everton for £280,000 in 1981, and his career declined due to persistent injury problems.
Saunders' Sudden Departure: A Shock to the Club
Aston Villa's success under Saunders made his sudden departure in February 1982 all the more shocking. At the time, the club had achieved significant milestones, including winning the League Championship for the first time in 71 years and reaching the European Cup quarter-finals. Despite these successes, there were underlying tensions between Saunders and the board.
Saunders had begun to take a more active role in the club's operations beyond managing the team. He involved himself in various aspects, from catering to programme sales, and expressed concerns over stadium maintenance expenses. His assertiveness did not sit well with the board, leading to disagreements over the direction of the club.
At a critical board meeting on February 2nd, Saunders proposed selling key players Tony Morley and Gary Shaw to fund new signings. The board rejected this idea, feeling that less important players should be considered for sale instead. This disagreement marked a significant rift between Saunders and the directors. As a result, the board served Saunders with a three-year notice on his contract, setting the stage for his unexpected resignation.
The Resignation: A Dramatic Turn of Events
A week after the contentious board meeting, Ron Saunders called Steve Stride, a close associate, to his home. He handed Stride his resignation letter and requested that he inform Chairman Ron Bendall immediately. Saunders wanted to witness Bendall's reaction firsthand, insisting that the call be made from his home.
When Stride relayed the news, Bendall's response was surprisingly indifferent. Despite Villa's ongoing European campaign, the club's league form had deteriorated, placing them 15th in the table after a humiliating 4-1 loss to Manchester United. Bendall viewed Saunders' resignation as an opportunity to part ways without triggering the substantial pay-off his contract entailed.
Saunders' departure left the club and its supporters in disbelief. It was the first time Saunders did not get his way since his appointment six years earlier. His unexpected exit hinted at deeper issues within the club's hierarchy, revealing that the relationship between the manager and the board had become strained.
Aftermath: Legal Battles and Reputation
The aftermath of Saunders' resignation was tumultuous. Accusing the board of interfering with his duties, Saunders issued a writ against Aston Villa. In response, the board threatened legal action if Saunders joined a rival club, Birmingham City, alleging he was breaking his contract.
Fortunately, the conflict was resolved without court proceedings. An agreement was reached where Saunders returned his car in good condition, and Aston Villa paid him £5,000. While this settlement avoided a protracted legal battle, it marked the end of Saunders' tumultuous tenure at Villa Park.
Saunders quickly found employment elsewhere, taking the managerial position at Birmingham City, Aston Villa's fierce local rivals. However, he never recaptured the success he had enjoyed at Villa Park. His time at Birmingham City did not reach the heights of his achievements with Aston Villa, though his reputation as a dedicated manager remained intact.
Peter Withe’s Continued Legacy at Aston Villa
Peter Withe's legacy at Aston Villa was cemented by his exceptional performances. Beyond the goals and the championship, Withe embodied the spirit and resilience of the team. His ability to perform under pressure, especially in crucial matches like the European Cup final, made him an icon among the fans.
Withe's success story also highlighted the importance of strategic decision-making in football management. While the board's initial refusal to fund Gilles signing Mick Ferguson could have been seen as restrictive, it ultimately led to acquiring a player whose impact was immeasurable. This episode underscores how pivotal moments and sometimes unexpected decisions can shape the destiny of a football club.
Reflections on Aston Villa’s Management Dynamics
The saga of Ron Saunders and Peter Withe provides valuable insights into the complexities of football club management. It illustrates how tensions between a manager's vision and the board's financial constraints can lead to significant changes within a club. Saunders' resignation, driven by disagreements over the club's direction and player acquisitions, serves as a reminder of the delicate balance required to maintain harmony and achieve success.
Aston Villa’s journey during this period was marked by highs of winning the League Championship and competing in Europe, juxtaposed with the lows of managerial disputes and financial strains. The ability of the club to navigate these challenges while maintaining competitiveness on the field is a testament to the resilience and strategic planning of its leadership.
The Enduring Impact on Aston Villa's Identity
The events surrounding Saunders' departure and Withe's rise have had a lasting impact on Aston Villa's identity. They highlight the club's ability to turn potential setbacks into stepping stones for greater achievements. The success story of Peter Withe remains a proud chapter in Villa's history, symbolizing the rewards of thoughtful recruitment and strong leadership.
Moreover, Saunders' tenure, despite its controversial end, is remembered fondly by many fans who cherish the championships and European exploits. His willingness to stand up for his vision, even at the cost of his position, reflects the passion and dedication that have long been synonymous with Aston Villa.
Conclusion: Lessons Learned and the Path Forward
The story of Ron Saunders and Peter Withe is more than just a tale of a manager's exit and a player's success. It encapsulates the intricate dynamics of football club management, the impact of strategic decisions, and the importance of aligning visions between the coaching staff and the board.
For Aston Villa, these lessons have undoubtedly influenced how the club approaches management decisions, player acquisitions, and internal relationships. As the club continues to build its future, the legacy of figures like Saunders and Withe serves as both inspiration and a guide, reminding everyone involved of the heights that can be achieved through dedication, strategy, and sometimes, bold decisions.
Aston Villa's journey is a testament to the enduring spirit of football, where legends are not just made on the field but also through the challenges and triumphs behind the scenes. The intertwined stories of Ron Saunders and Peter Withe will forever be a pivotal part of Villa Park’s illustrious history, celebrated by fans for generations to come.
